Jack Kelly – Chris Arellano
Katherine Plumber – Jaimasan Sutton
Davey – Cameron Illidge-Welch
Les – Lucca Giannini
Crutchie – Hannah Lilly
Medda Larkin – Sheneille Wilson
Wiesel – Eddie Dethlefs (Stage Manager, Mr. Jacobi, Mayor)
Pulitzer – Zane Barker
Roosevelt – William Strohl (Nunzio, Guard, Policeman)
Hannah – Emily Carvey (Nun)
Bowery Beauties – Rhea Richardson and Kyra Sprague
Darcy – Daniel Moses
Nuns – Kyra Sprague, Rhea Richardson, Emily Carver
Morris Delancey – Louie Giannini
Oscar Delancey – Daniel Moses
Snyder – Bingham Bright
Seitz – Dave Waldron
Bunsen – Nathen Illidge-Welch
Bill Hearst – Nathen Illidge-Welch